Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

[Merged by Bors] - Add lcli block-root tool #3580

Closed
wants to merge 4 commits into from
Closed

[Merged by Bors] - Add lcli block-root tool #3580

wants to merge 4 commits into from

Conversation

paulhauner
Copy link
Member

Issue Addressed

NA

Proposed Changes

Adds a simple tool for computing the block root of some block from a beacon-API or a file. This is useful for benchmarking.

Additional Info

NA

@paulhauner paulhauner added ready-for-review The code is ready for review low-hanging-fruit Easy to resolve, get it before someone else does! labels Sep 15, 2022
@paulhauner paulhauner mentioned this pull request Sep 15, 2022
Closed
michaelsproul
michaelsproul approved these changes Sep 15, 2022
View reviewed changes
Copy link
Member

@michaelsproul michaelsproul left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Nice!

@michaelsproul michaelsproul added ready-for-merge This PR is ready to merge. v3.1.2 Release after v3.1.0 (formerly v3.1.1) and removed ready-for-review The code is ready for review labels Sep 15, 2022
@paulhauner
Copy link
Member Author

bors r+

bors bot pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 16, 2022
@paulhauner
Add lcli block-root tool (#3580)
2f53892 
## Issue Addressed

NA

## Proposed Changes

Adds a simple tool for computing the block root of some block from a beacon-API or a file. This is useful for benchmarking.

## Additional Info

NA
bors bot pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 16, 2022
@paulhauner
Use SmallVec for TreeHash packed encoding (#3581)
80f5628 
## Issue Addressed

NA

## Proposed Changes

I've noticed that our block hashing times increase significantly after the merge. I did some flamegraph-ing and noticed that we're allocating a `Vec` for each byte of each execution payload transaction. This seems like unnecessary work and a bit of a fragmentation risk.

This PR switches to `SmallVec<[u8; 32]>` for the packed encoding of `TreeHash`. I believe this is a nice simple optimisation with no downside.

### Benchmarking

These numbers were computed using #3580 on my desktop (i7 hex-core). You can see a bit of noise in the numbers, that's probably just my computer doing other things. Generally I found this change takes the time from 10-11ms to 8-9ms. I can also see all the allocations disappear from flamegraph.

This is the block being benchmarked: https://beaconcha.in/slot/4704236

#### Before

```
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 980: 10.553003ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 981: 10.563737ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 982: 10.646352ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 983: 10.628532ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 984: 10.552112ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 985: 10.587778ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 986: 10.640526ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 987: 10.587243ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 988: 10.554748ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 989: 10.551111ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 990: 11.559031ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 991: 11.944827ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 992: 10.554308ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 993: 11.043397ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 994: 11.043315ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 995: 11.207711ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 996: 11.056246ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 997: 11.049706ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 998: 11.432449ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 999: 11.149617ms
```

#### After

```
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 980: 14.011653ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 981: 8.925314ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 982: 8.849563ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 983: 8.893689ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 984: 8.902964ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 985: 8.942067ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 986: 8.907088ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 987: 9.346101ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 988: 8.96142ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 989: 9.366437ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 990: 9.809334ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 991: 9.541561ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 992: 11.143518ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 993: 10.821181ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 994: 9.855973ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 995: 10.941006ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 996: 9.596155ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 997: 9.121739ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 998: 9.090019ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 999: 9.071885ms
```

## Additional Info

Please provide any additional information. For example, future considerations
or information useful for reviewers.
@bors
Copy link

bors bot commented Sep 16, 2022

Build failed (retrying...):

@bors
Copy link

bors bot commented Sep 16, 2022

Canceled.

@paulhauner
Copy link
Member Author

bors r-

@paulhauner
Copy link
Member Author

bors r+

bors bot pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 16, 2022
@paulhauner
Add lcli block-root tool (#3580)
1b53f30 
## Issue Addressed

NA

## Proposed Changes

Adds a simple tool for computing the block root of some block from a beacon-API or a file. This is useful for benchmarking.

## Additional Info

NA
bors bot pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 16, 2022
@paulhauner
Use SmallVec for TreeHash packed encoding (#3581)
082ca33 
## Issue Addressed

NA

## Proposed Changes

I've noticed that our block hashing times increase significantly after the merge. I did some flamegraph-ing and noticed that we're allocating a `Vec` for each byte of each execution payload transaction. This seems like unnecessary work and a bit of a fragmentation risk.

This PR switches to `SmallVec<[u8; 32]>` for the packed encoding of `TreeHash`. I believe this is a nice simple optimisation with no downside.

### Benchmarking

These numbers were computed using #3580 on my desktop (i7 hex-core). You can see a bit of noise in the numbers, that's probably just my computer doing other things. Generally I found this change takes the time from 10-11ms to 8-9ms. I can also see all the allocations disappear from flamegraph.

This is the block being benchmarked: https://beaconcha.in/slot/4704236

#### Before

```
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 980: 10.553003ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 981: 10.563737ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 982: 10.646352ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 983: 10.628532ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 984: 10.552112ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 985: 10.587778ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 986: 10.640526ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 987: 10.587243ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 988: 10.554748ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 989: 10.551111ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 990: 11.559031ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 991: 11.944827ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 992: 10.554308ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 993: 11.043397ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 994: 11.043315ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 995: 11.207711ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 996: 11.056246ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 997: 11.049706ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 998: 11.432449ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 999: 11.149617ms
```

#### After

```
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 980: 14.011653ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 981: 8.925314ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 982: 8.849563ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 983: 8.893689ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 984: 8.902964ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 985: 8.942067ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 986: 8.907088ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 987: 9.346101ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 988: 8.96142ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 989: 9.366437ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 990: 9.809334ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 991: 9.541561ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 992: 11.143518ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 993: 10.821181ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 994: 9.855973ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 995: 10.941006ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 996: 9.596155ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 997: 9.121739ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 998: 9.090019ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 999: 9.071885ms
```

## Additional Info

Please provide any additional information. For example, future considerations
or information useful for reviewers.
@paulhauner
Copy link
Member Author

bors r-

@bors
Copy link

bors bot commented Sep 16, 2022

This PR was included in a batch that was canceled, it will be automatically retried

@bors
Copy link

bors bot commented Sep 16, 2022

Canceled.

@paulhauner
Copy link
Member Author

bors r+

bors bot pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 16, 2022
@paulhauner
Add lcli block-root tool (#3580)
dff535a 
## Issue Addressed

NA

## Proposed Changes

Adds a simple tool for computing the block root of some block from a beacon-API or a file. This is useful for benchmarking.

## Additional Info

NA
bors bot pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 16, 2022
@paulhauner
Use SmallVec for TreeHash packed encoding (#3581)
eb3d835 
## Issue Addressed

NA

## Proposed Changes

I've noticed that our block hashing times increase significantly after the merge. I did some flamegraph-ing and noticed that we're allocating a `Vec` for each byte of each execution payload transaction. This seems like unnecessary work and a bit of a fragmentation risk.

This PR switches to `SmallVec<[u8; 32]>` for the packed encoding of `TreeHash`. I believe this is a nice simple optimisation with no downside.

### Benchmarking

These numbers were computed using #3580 on my desktop (i7 hex-core). You can see a bit of noise in the numbers, that's probably just my computer doing other things. Generally I found this change takes the time from 10-11ms to 8-9ms. I can also see all the allocations disappear from flamegraph.

This is the block being benchmarked: https://beaconcha.in/slot/4704236

#### Before

```
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 980: 10.553003ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 981: 10.563737ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 982: 10.646352ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 983: 10.628532ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 984: 10.552112ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 985: 10.587778ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 986: 10.640526ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 987: 10.587243ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 988: 10.554748ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 989: 10.551111ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 990: 11.559031ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 991: 11.944827ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 992: 10.554308ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 993: 11.043397ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 994: 11.043315ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 995: 11.207711ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 996: 11.056246ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 997: 11.049706ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 998: 11.432449ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 999: 11.149617ms
```

#### After

```
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 980: 14.011653ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 981: 8.925314ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 982: 8.849563ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 983: 8.893689ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 984: 8.902964ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 985: 8.942067ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 986: 8.907088ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 987: 9.346101ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 988: 8.96142ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 989: 9.366437ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 990: 9.809334ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 991: 9.541561ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 992: 11.143518ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 993: 10.821181ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 994: 9.855973ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 995: 10.941006ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 996: 9.596155ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 997: 9.121739ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 998: 9.090019ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 999: 9.071885ms
```

## Additional Info

Please provide any additional information. For example, future considerations
or information useful for reviewers.
@bors
Copy link

bors bot commented Sep 16, 2022

Build failed (retrying...):

bors bot pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 16, 2022
@paulhauner
Add lcli block-root tool (#3580)
bde3c16 
## Issue Addressed

NA

## Proposed Changes

Adds a simple tool for computing the block root of some block from a beacon-API or a file. This is useful for benchmarking.

## Additional Info

NA
bors bot pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 16, 2022
@paulhauner
Use SmallVec for TreeHash packed encoding (#3581)
b0b606d 
## Issue Addressed

NA

## Proposed Changes

I've noticed that our block hashing times increase significantly after the merge. I did some flamegraph-ing and noticed that we're allocating a `Vec` for each byte of each execution payload transaction. This seems like unnecessary work and a bit of a fragmentation risk.

This PR switches to `SmallVec<[u8; 32]>` for the packed encoding of `TreeHash`. I believe this is a nice simple optimisation with no downside.

### Benchmarking

These numbers were computed using #3580 on my desktop (i7 hex-core). You can see a bit of noise in the numbers, that's probably just my computer doing other things. Generally I found this change takes the time from 10-11ms to 8-9ms. I can also see all the allocations disappear from flamegraph.

This is the block being benchmarked: https://beaconcha.in/slot/4704236

#### Before

```
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 980: 10.553003ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 981: 10.563737ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 982: 10.646352ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 983: 10.628532ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 984: 10.552112ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 985: 10.587778ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 986: 10.640526ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 987: 10.587243ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 988: 10.554748ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 989: 10.551111ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 990: 11.559031ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 991: 11.944827ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 992: 10.554308ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 993: 11.043397ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 994: 11.043315ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 995: 11.207711ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 996: 11.056246ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 997: 11.049706ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 998: 11.432449ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 999: 11.149617ms
```

#### After

```
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 980: 14.011653ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 981: 8.925314ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 982: 8.849563ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 983: 8.893689ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 984: 8.902964ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 985: 8.942067ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 986: 8.907088ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 987: 9.346101ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 988: 8.96142ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 989: 9.366437ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 990: 9.809334ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 991: 9.541561ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 992: 11.143518ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 993: 10.821181ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 994: 9.855973ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 995: 10.941006ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 996: 9.596155ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 997: 9.121739ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 998: 9.090019ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 999: 9.071885ms
```

## Additional Info

Please provide any additional information. For example, future considerations
or information useful for reviewers.
@bors
Copy link

bors bot commented Sep 16, 2022

Pull request successfully merged into unstable.

Build succeeded:

@bors bors bot changed the title Add lcli block-root tool [Merged by Bors] - Add lcli block-root tool Sep 16, 2022
@bors bors bot closed this Sep 16, 2022
Woodpile37 pushed a commit to Woodpile37/lighthouse that referenced this pull request Jan 6, 2024
@paulhauner @Woodpile37
Add lcli block-root tool (sigp#3580)
28ef628 
## Issue Addressed

NA

## Proposed Changes

Adds a simple tool for computing the block root of some block from a beacon-API or a file. This is useful for benchmarking.

## Additional Info

NA
Woodpile37 pushed a commit to Woodpile37/lighthouse that referenced this pull request Jan 6, 2024
@paulhauner @Woodpile37
Use SmallVec for TreeHash packed encoding (sigp#3581)
d58d458 
## Issue Addressed

NA

## Proposed Changes

I've noticed that our block hashing times increase significantly after the merge. I did some flamegraph-ing and noticed that we're allocating a `Vec` for each byte of each execution payload transaction. This seems like unnecessary work and a bit of a fragmentation risk.

This PR switches to `SmallVec<[u8; 32]>` for the packed encoding of `TreeHash`. I believe this is a nice simple optimisation with no downside.

### Benchmarking

These numbers were computed using sigp#3580 on my desktop (i7 hex-core). You can see a bit of noise in the numbers, that's probably just my computer doing other things. Generally I found this change takes the time from 10-11ms to 8-9ms. I can also see all the allocations disappear from flamegraph.

This is the block being benchmarked: https://beaconcha.in/slot/4704236

#### Before

```
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 980: 10.553003ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 981: 10.563737ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 982: 10.646352ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 983: 10.628532ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 984: 10.552112ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 985: 10.587778ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 986: 10.640526ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 987: 10.587243ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 988: 10.554748ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 989: 10.551111ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 990: 11.559031ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 991: 11.944827ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 992: 10.554308ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 993: 11.043397ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 994: 11.043315ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 995: 11.207711ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 996: 11.056246ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 997: 11.049706ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 998: 11.432449ms
[2022-09-15T21:44:19Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 999: 11.149617ms
```

#### After

```
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 980: 14.011653ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 981: 8.925314ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 982: 8.849563ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 983: 8.893689ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 984: 8.902964ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 985: 8.942067ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 986: 8.907088ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 987: 9.346101ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 988: 8.96142ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 989: 9.366437ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 990: 9.809334ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 991: 9.541561ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 992: 11.143518ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 993: 10.821181ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 994: 9.855973ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 995: 10.941006ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 996: 9.596155ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 997: 9.121739ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 998: 9.090019ms
[2022-09-15T21:41:49Z INFO  lcli::block_root] Run 999: 9.071885ms
```

## Additional Info

Please provide any additional information. For example, future considerations
or information useful for reviewers.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Reviewers

@michaelsproul michaelsproul michaelsproul approved these changes

Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
low-hanging-fruit Easy to resolve, get it before someone else does! ready-for-merge This PR is ready to merge. v3.1.2 Release after v3.1.0 (formerly v3.1.1)
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.
2 participants
@paulhauner @michaelsproul