Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

[STF] Safrole gamma_s uses eta_3' instead of eta_2' #43

Closed
ggwpez opened this issue Feb 10, 2025 · 1 comment
Closed

[STF] Safrole gamma_s uses eta_3' instead of eta_2' #43

ggwpez opened this issue Feb 10, 2025 · 1 comment

Comments

@ggwpez
Copy link

ggwpez commented Feb 10, 2025

Around here, there should be the state for the current seal key series gamma_s. Gamma s is to be updated in this transition to the fallback series - which happens correctly.

"0x0400000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",

However, the GrayMatter client arrives at a different seal key series. As comparison:

Colorful Nation gamma_s'

[
	"AA2B95F7572875B0D0F186552AE745BA8222FC0B5BD456554BFE51C68938F8BC",
	"5E465BEB01DBAFE160CE8216047F2155DD0569F058AFD52DCEA601025A8D161D",
	"48E5FCDCE10E0B64EC4EEBD0D9211C7BAC2F27CE54BCA6F7776FF6FEE86AB3E3",
	"3D5E5A51AAB2B048F8686ECD79712A80E3265A114CC73F14BDB2A59233FB66D0",
	"3D5E5A51AAB2B048F8686ECD79712A80E3265A114CC73F14BDB2A59233FB66D0",
	"5E465BEB01DBAFE160CE8216047F2155DD0569F058AFD52DCEA601025A8D161D",
	"F16E5352840AFB47E206B5C89F560F2611835855CF2E6EBAD1ACC9520A72591D",
	"3D5E5A51AAB2B048F8686ECD79712A80E3265A114CC73F14BDB2A59233FB66D0",
	"AA2B95F7572875B0D0F186552AE745BA8222FC0B5BD456554BFE51C68938F8BC",
	"AA2B95F7572875B0D0F186552AE745BA8222FC0B5BD456554BFE51C68938F8BC",
	"3D5E5A51AAB2B048F8686ECD79712A80E3265A114CC73F14BDB2A59233FB66D0",
	"48E5FCDCE10E0B64EC4EEBD0D9211C7BAC2F27CE54BCA6F7776FF6FEE86AB3E3"
]

GrayMatter gamma_s'

[
	"48E5FCDCE10E0B64EC4EEBD0D9211C7BAC2F27CE54BCA6F7776FF6FEE86AB3E3",
	"48E5FCDCE10E0B64EC4EEBD0D9211C7BAC2F27CE54BCA6F7776FF6FEE86AB3E3",
	"48E5FCDCE10E0B64EC4EEBD0D9211C7BAC2F27CE54BCA6F7776FF6FEE86AB3E3",
	"F16E5352840AFB47E206B5C89F560F2611835855CF2E6EBAD1ACC9520A72591D",
	"5E465BEB01DBAFE160CE8216047F2155DD0569F058AFD52DCEA601025A8D161D",
	"48E5FCDCE10E0B64EC4EEBD0D9211C7BAC2F27CE54BCA6F7776FF6FEE86AB3E3",
	"5E465BEB01DBAFE160CE8216047F2155DD0569F058AFD52DCEA601025A8D161D",
	"48E5FCDCE10E0B64EC4EEBD0D9211C7BAC2F27CE54BCA6F7776FF6FEE86AB3E3",
	"3D5E5A51AAB2B048F8686ECD79712A80E3265A114CC73F14BDB2A59233FB66D0",
	"5E465BEB01DBAFE160CE8216047F2155DD0569F058AFD52DCEA601025A8D161D",
	"3D5E5A51AAB2B048F8686ECD79712A80E3265A114CC73F14BDB2A59233FB66D0",
	"48E5FCDCE10E0B64EC4EEBD0D9211C7BAC2F27CE54BCA6F7776FF6FEE86AB3E3"
]

I think I know what is wrong in your client, as since when I switched my code to use eta_3' here instead of eta_2', then i arrive at that same sequence. But it should be eta_2', see https://graypaper.fluffylabs.dev/#/5f542d7/0e92020e9602

Image

@ggwpez
Copy link
Author

ggwpez commented Feb 11, 2025

LGTM, thanks!

@ggwpez ggwpez closed this as completed Feb 11, 2025
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant